Gluten Free Cookie Butter

Creamy gluten free cookie butter- perfect for toast, apples, or to just eat with a spoon! You just can’t go wrong with it!

Gluten Free Cookie Butter

This post is part of a collaboration between Goodie Girl Cookies and My Gluten Free Miami. All opinions are my own.

Gluten Free Cookie Butter

Have you tried cookie butter? I hadn’t. I had heard about it. When Trader Joe’s first opened in Miami everyone was so excited about the cookie butter and I had no idea what they were talking about. Since I couldn’t eat it, I never really thought about it, but was always curious.

Who knew it was so incredibly simple to make it on your own. I now know what all the buzz is about!

Gluten Free Cookie Butter with Apples

Goodie Girl Toffee Crunch

One of my favorite Goodie Girl flavors is Toffee Crunch (I love them all, but Toffee bits in cookies is always a winner!). These crispy cookies with toffee and chocolate chips make a killer gluten free cookie butter!

The flavor of these cookies in this gluten free cookie butter is amazing. Plus, the creamy texture makes it spread just like peanut butter.

You can see below how it easy it is to make!

Simple Ingredients, Easy Steps

Gluten free cookie butter only has a few ingredients to make it into the creamy spread. You will want to eat this on everything! All you need is a food processor, a crunchy style cookie, butter, sugar, and cream.

Blend it all together and you are done!


You can eat cookie butter on just about anything. Think about all the things people use Nutella for and just use homemade gluten free cookie butter instead! It’s perfect for:

  • Toast
  • Apples
  • Bananas
  • On Ice Cream
  • Sandwiched between two cookies
  • On cake
  • With a spoonGluten Free Cookie Butter with Toast

This stuff is so good, you are going to wonder why you never thought to make this easy, homemade gluten free cookie butter before. Grab some cookies and find out what all the cookie butter hype is about!

You can get Goodie Girl cookies in stores and on their website! Be sure to check out some of the other great recipes using their cookies, including this Gluten Free Ice Cream Cake that’s just like Carvel or these easy Gluten Free Oatmeal Cookie Magic bars. So many great ways to enjoy Goodie Girl Cookies!

Happy Gluten Free Eating!

Gluten Free Cookie Butter

Gluten Free Cookie Butter
Rate this recipe
9 ratings
Category: Dessert
Cuisine: American

  • 1 Box Gluten Free Cookies (I used Goodie Girl Toffee Crunch
  • 1 Tablespoon melted butter
  • 2 Tablespoons brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream

  1. Grind cookies in a food processor until fine crumbs.
  2. Add melted butter, sugar and heavy cream.
  3. Blend until smooth.
  4. Serve on toast, apples, bananas or anything you like!

Prep Time: 5 minutes Yield: 10
121.4 kcal
9.26 g
5.79 g
9.42 g
0.38 g
9.26 g
20.44 mg
0.12 g
31.11 mg
Nutrition label for Gluten Free Cookie Butter
Recipe Management Powered by Zip Recipes Plugin

Related Post

36 thoughts on “Gluten Free Cookie Butter

  1. I shop at Trader Joe’s all the time, but have never heard of cookie butter. This sounds heavenly! I will have to check it out. Is it just me or is Trader Joe’s always so busy you feel like you can’t really browse?

  2. Oh my word! I love cookie butter! I have never tried to make my own, and think I certainly could with this recipe. Can’t wait!

  3. omg i have a friend who is obsessed with cookie butter and would love this. i should totally make this for her for her upcoming potluck she is having she would love it.

  4. Oh my heavens to betsy! I’m going to have to try this ASAP! We LOVE Trader Joe’s cookie butter but I’d love to be able to make it at home myself! I’m super excited for this! Thanks!

  5. My girls would love this! Maybe I should make a batch and sneak it in the cupboard and see how long it takes for them to try it. If I put cookie butter on it it would disappear!

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: